I often scroll through peevish threads on social media about bastardizing food and (dis)honoring authenticity, often in semantics. A food blogger sighs over gratuitous descriptors like ‘Greek yogurt and Persian cucumber for a Raita Sauce’.
While I am not going to brood over localizing recipes to convey essence of a foreign cuisine, I can’t deny the twitchy indignation in my gut when I see the ‘lentil stew, seasoned with turmeric and spices finished with a tempering of whole spices flash fried in oil’ byline for a Dal at an Indian restaurant, celebrating Indian cuisine, in an Indian city.
Contrast this with the sweeping assumptions that American fast food chains make about their prosaic Hamburgers and frothy Lattes. I confess to sheepishly spending a minute or two skimming images and pronunciations, before placing my order at fine dine Italian restaurants. Something seems amiss to me, if Indian restaurants and hotels are spending so much letter & ink highlighting the nuances between Ciabattas and Focaccias while relegating our array of Chapati, Phulka, Roti, Naan and Paranthas under Flatbread.
Just for kicks, I decided to turn the tables and see how do popular European/American dishes work out when translated for the Hindi reader.
Pizzas: मैदे की मोटी या पतली नान पे टमाटर की चटनी और चीज़. इसके ऊपर गोष्ट, और सब्ज़ियां भी डाल सकते
Mayde ki moti ya patli naan pe tamatar ki chutney aur cheese. Iske upar gosht, aur sabziyan bhi daal sakte hai.
Pasta: सूजी की वादी विशेष प्रकार में. उबाल कर, टमाटर की चटनी और चीज़ या फिर माखन और ओलिव के तेल के साथ.
Sooji ki vadi vishesh prakar mein. Ubal kar, tamatar ki chutney aur cheese ya fir makhan aur olive ke Tel ke sath.
Burger: डॉ डबल रोटी के बीच में एक शमी कबाब या आलू टिक्की, टमाटर, सॉस, पत्ते और चीज़
Doa double roti ke beech me ek shami kabab ya aloo tikki, tamatar, sauce, patte aur cheese
Risotto: चिपकीलये चावल की खिचड़ी
Chipkeelye chawal ki khichdi
French Fries: लंबे कटे हुए आलू की भुजिया
Lambe katte hue aloo ki bhujiya
Corn on the Cob: उबला हुआ भुट्टा
Ubla hua bhutta
Crisp Tacos: मक्की का मसाला पापड़
Makki ka masala papad
Steak, medium rare: बड़े का बड़ा बोती, ताव भुना. बीच में थोडा कच्चा.
Bade ka bada boti, tava bhuna. beech mein thoda kacha.
Scrambled Eggs: गीला अंडा भुर्जी.
Geela Anda Bhurji
Eggs Benedicts: माखन लगा के पो पे पानी में उबला हुआ हलफबोयल अंडा, उसके ऊपर पीले का सॉस.
Makhan laga ke pao pe paani mein ubla hua halfboil anda, uske upar peele ka sauce
Crepes: कुट्टू के आटे का डोसा.
Kuttu ke aate ka Dosa
Hindi script courtesy Google translate; a few words are off-center but you should get the meaning.
Do you think restaurants should start including (more apt) Hindi descriptors, or the idea is beyond the pale? Suggest more Western dishes, Hindi mein in comments section below.
While I am not going to brood over localizing recipes to convey essence of a foreign cuisine, I can’t deny the twitchy indignation in my gut when I see the ‘lentil stew, seasoned with turmeric and spices finished with a tempering of whole spices flash fried in oil’ byline for a Dal at an Indian restaurant, celebrating Indian cuisine, in an Indian city.
Contrast this with the sweeping assumptions that American fast food chains make about their prosaic Hamburgers and frothy Lattes. I confess to sheepishly spending a minute or two skimming images and pronunciations, before placing my order at fine dine Italian restaurants. Something seems amiss to me, if Indian restaurants and hotels are spending so much letter & ink highlighting the nuances between Ciabattas and Focaccias while relegating our array of Chapati, Phulka, Roti, Naan and Paranthas under Flatbread.
Just for kicks, I decided to turn the tables and see how do popular European/American dishes work out when translated for the Hindi reader.
Pizzas: मैदे की मोटी या पतली नान पे टमाटर की चटनी और चीज़. इसके ऊपर गोष्ट, और सब्ज़ियां भी डाल सकते
Mayde ki moti ya patli naan pe tamatar ki chutney aur cheese. Iske upar gosht, aur sabziyan bhi daal sakte hai.
Pasta: सूजी की वादी विशेष प्रकार में. उबाल कर, टमाटर की चटनी और चीज़ या फिर माखन और ओलिव के तेल के साथ.
Sooji ki vadi vishesh prakar mein. Ubal kar, tamatar ki chutney aur cheese ya fir makhan aur olive ke Tel ke sath.
Burger: डॉ डबल रोटी के बीच में एक शमी कबाब या आलू टिक्की, टमाटर, सॉस, पत्ते और चीज़
Doa double roti ke beech me ek shami kabab ya aloo tikki, tamatar, sauce, patte aur cheese
Risotto: चिपकीलये चावल की खिचड़ी
Chipkeelye chawal ki khichdi
French Fries: लंबे कटे हुए आलू की भुजिया
Lambe katte hue aloo ki bhujiya
Corn on the Cob: उबला हुआ भुट्टा
Ubla hua bhutta
Crisp Tacos: मक्की का मसाला पापड़
Makki ka masala papad
Steak, medium rare: बड़े का बड़ा बोती, ताव भुना. बीच में थोडा कच्चा.
Bade ka bada boti, tava bhuna. beech mein thoda kacha.
Scrambled Eggs: गीला अंडा भुर्जी.
Geela Anda Bhurji
Eggs Benedicts: माखन लगा के पो पे पानी में उबला हुआ हलफबोयल अंडा, उसके ऊपर पीले का सॉस.
Makhan laga ke pao pe paani mein ubla hua halfboil anda, uske upar peele ka sauce
Crepes: कुट्टू के आटे का डोसा.
Kuttu ke aate ka Dosa
Hindi script courtesy Google translate; a few words are off-center but you should get the meaning.
Do you think restaurants should start including (more apt) Hindi descriptors, or the idea is beyond the pale? Suggest more Western dishes, Hindi mein in comments section below.
Just an fyi for you next time just put them in the oven! I dont fry anything anymore everything that is supposed to be fried gets baked and I actually like it better and its so much healthier for you...Just thought I would share that tip with you.....
ReplyDeletee-mail with love free online
apps mobile e-mail with love online 2018
koi Nhật
New blogs are emerging the whole single one one of minute. Learn how to begin a blog of your own.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing the post.. parents are worlds best person in each lives of individual..they need or must succeed to sustain needs of the family
currency converter app download
currency converter online
I'm fond of your posts. They contain interesting information and meaningful messages. I like them and read new posts when they are released. I wish you can write and upload more articles. Thanks for sharing them.
ReplyDeletehttps://autoketing.com/
https://bit.ly/2BWQsAw
https://bit.ly/2BXG37u